Ten years ago, we were cast out of our “Texas Baptists” family 
by Bill Jones

(NOTE: Over the past 10 years, I’ve written numerous blog posts related to this issue. I’m “sprinkling” [admittedly contrary to Baptist doctrine, lol] links to those posts throughout this essay. You might find them helpful supplements to the current post.)

Ten years ago this week, specifically Tuesday, November 15, 2016, messengers to the annual meeting of the Baptist General Convention of Texas (BGCT) in Waco voted to expel—as “out of harmonious cooperation”—any churches welcoming people identifying as LGBTQ+.

Three churches were ultimately cast out into the cold: Lake Shore Drive, Waco; First, Austin; and Wilshire, Dallas, my home church.

A few hours earlier, at what turned out to be our final Texas Baptists Committed (TBC) breakfast at the BGCT (TBC ceased operations at the end of July 2017), I focused my remarks, as TBC executive director, on calling this motion, which had been initiated and endorsed by David Hardage, BGCT executive director, a violation of the historic and treasured Baptist principle of local church autonomy.

When I made those remarks, I knew that Wilshire and First Austin were targets of this motion; I did not know that Lake Shore Drive in Waco was in the process of taking similar steps to welcome LGBTQ+ people. However, I had happened to invite Lake Shore Drive’s pastor, Kyndall Rae Rothaus, to give the invocation, and she was a guest at my table. When I returned to my seat from delivering my remarks, Kyndall leaned over and whispered, “Thank you.” It was only later that I understood why she was thanking me.

I had asked my friend, Todd Still, dean of Baylor’s Truett Seminary, to invite seminary students to the breakfast as guests of TBC, and about 10 were in attendance. A few minutes after my remarks, I noticed one of the students get up to leave, likely because he needed to get to class. On his way out, he walked over to me, leaned over, and whispered, “Thank you.”

Throughout the day, several BGCT staffers stopped by the TBC booth to thank me, too; they couldn’t say so publicly, of course, or they would have likely lost their jobs.

11/19/2016: REALLY? One disagreement, and we throw away all that we share?

The vote that day was not unanimous. In fact, it was so close that they had to take the vote three times in different ways just to get an accurate count. That’s the only time I had ever seen that happen in years of attending BGCT meetings. The discussion prior to the vote was ended prematurely. Kyndall had stepped to the microphone to speak against the motion. However, because of the rule that the two positions – for and against – had to rotate, she had to step back and allow someone to first speak for the motion. In one of the most unChristian and unethical actions I have ever seen taken by a messenger at such a meeting or even in a church business meeting, this man – who clearly knew that Kyndall was graciously awaiting her turn to speak against the motion – called for the question, thus ending all discussion. After the vote, several of us accompanied Kyndall out into the hall, where she was distraught, having been denied her opportunity to speak.

Officially, the vote kicked the responsibility for identifying churches “out of harmonious cooperation” on this issue to the BGCT Executive Board at its next quarterly meeting. In February 2017, I attended the Executive Board meeting. Steve Vernon, my dear friend who was BGCT associate executive director, always graciously invited me to these meetings as a guest because of the BGCT’s longtime relationship with TBC. It would turn out to be my last such meeting, as TBC would go out of existence later that year.

At that meeting, I sat with other guests and observers along the back wall. But I wasn’t observing idly; I was blogging. My post was entitled, When family doesn’t want you anymore. For me, and for Wilshire Baptist Church, the BGCT was family. I had numerous friends on the staff. Many years earlier, Wilshire’s own Phil Strickland, then director of the BGCT Christian Life Commission, founded the convention’s Hunger Offering. Phil had passed away in 2006. I couldn’t help but think of him on this day, how his heart would break upon seeing his BGCT family reject his church family.

Our pastor, George Mason, even asked BGCT leadership to allow Wilshire—even without voting rights—to continue giving financially to the Hunger Offering that was dear to our hearts, as well as to the Texas Baptist schools that we loved, and other BGCT ministries that were special to us. Their reply? No dice! Hmmm, brings to mind one description Stephen used in Acts for certain religious leaders of his day: “stiff-necked.”

8/4/2018: BGCT “unified” in conformity, returning to the Southern Baptist Convention, Part 1

When the Executive Board met the evening before the vote, the board chair passionately urged a “yes” vote on the motion to remove the “offending” churches, saying, “tomorrow we will vote to call sin sin, to refuse to affirm sinful behavior.” I thought it inappropriate for the chair of a board to take a partisan role in endorsing a particular position on a vote, particularly on such a controversial and divisive matter. Several years later, at an unrelated meeting, I found myself in the same room with this gentleman, and I mentioned his role in the action that expelled my church from the BGCT. His response floored me: “I was just following orders!”

Hmmm, where have we heard that before? It just confirmed to me, however, the coercive nature of BGCT leadership at that time, that – according to him – he had been “ordered” by BGCT leadership to lobby for passage of this motion. I had personally felt the sting of that leadership’s coercion, so it was no surprise. One difference, though – such efforts made me more determined to stick to my convictions. I thought it pretty weaselly for this gentleman to pass the buck rather than take responsibility for his own convictions – whatever they were – on this matter.

8/25/2018: TBC’s legacy, my own journey, and a few of the key people in both (remarks to my retirement dinner)

The attitude of BGCT leaders and messengers contrasts with that of George Mason on the Sunday before the BGCT vote. That was when Wilshire completed our vote to treat Wilshire members identifying as LGBTQ+ as fully equal members—with the same privileges as everyone else, to serve as deacons, Sunday School teachers, committee members; to marry at Wilshire; to have their children dedicated at Wilshire, and so forth.

Because members were required to be present in the sanctuary during the vote, we took it over two Sundays to give everyone ample opportunity. On that second Sunday, November 13, George Mason showed as much, or perhaps more, grace than I have ever seen displayed by a pastor toward his church before or since (that covers a lot of territory, seeing as how I’m 75 and have been in Baptist churches all my life).

2/15/2020: Closing Logsdon Seminary: A ‘financial’ decision, or what?

Because I’m doing this from memory, I won’t use quotation marks here, but I think I can give you the gist of what George said that morning, because it is burned onto the hard drive of my memory:

This will be the last time that all of us will be in this room together. After hearing the results of this vote, some of you may choose to leave Wilshire. For those of you who decide to leave, I have just one thing to say to you: THANK YOU. Thank you for all you have given to our church, in so many ways, over the years. You will always be welcome here, and we will always love you.

I couldn’t even write that just now, 10 years later, without getting some sizable lumps in my throat and tears in my eyes.

Two days after the Executive Board made our expulsion official in February 2017, my son Travis was in the hospital after suffering a seizure. George Mason came out to visit him. When he left, I walked with George back to the hospital entrance. As we walked, I shared with him about being in the room as the Executive Board deliberated and voted.

2/17/2020: Saving Logsdon Seminary . . . A “lost cause”? . . . they’re the only causes worth fighting for

George’s face brightened, and he said, “But you know what, Bill? Now we’re free to be the church God wants us to be.” To which I could only reply, “Amen!”

There’s a little more to this story that I feel compelled to share.

On the Sunday following Wilshire’s vote, Joanna and I arrived at church to find a group of people clustered around the front entrance, protesting our decision and shouting at us. I don’t remember specifics, but I imagine they were saying that we were welcoming and affirming sinners (hmmm, sounds a little like Jesus, doesn’t it?) and the like. Sheesh, if that church hadn’t welcomed sinners, it would have been empty every Sunday!

2/22/2020: 1990: Fundamentalist Takeover of the SBC; 2020: Fundamentalist Takeover of the BGCT

Keep in mind that these were not Wilshire members who had lost the vote; they were people who had read about our decision and showed up to display their holier-than-thou wares before the world. I doubt that they even lived near Wilshire.

The next Sunday was very different. The community around Wilshire rallied around us. They showed up to shout down the protesters and let us know that they supported our decision to love and welcome “every body,” as George likes to say.

As far as I know, that was the last we saw of those protesters. Love won the day.

7/22/2023: Of blind guides, gnats, & camels: Texas Baptists join Southern Baptists in elevating patriarchy and a haughty spirit

Yes, we lost members after that vote, just as George predicted. But through the years we have gained members who, whether identifying as LGBTQ+ or not, want to be part of a church that welcomes every body, a church that puts Jesus first by following his example to put love first.

As for our former family at the BGCT? They have continued to expand their ministry of exclusion and draw closer to the Southern Baptist model of hatred for those who think differently than them.

In 2020, Hardin-Simmons University shut down Logsdon Seminary because it was practicing too much of that Jesus love that Wilshire practiced. David Hardage, unsurprisingly, was behind that initiative.

8/15/2023: REVIEW – The Word Made Fresh: Preaching God’s Love for Every Body (GEORGE A. MASON)

At their annual meeting this week in 2026, 10 years after voting to remove Wilshire and our friends in Austin and Waco, they approved motions that will further tighten the screws of exclusion.

It’s tragic. We hardly recognize our family anymore.

Leave a Reply